Question

Is it permissible to say "Allah and His Messenger knows best?"

Answer

Today it would be impermissible. When a person says Allah taala knows best it means that concerning a particular issue his knowledge is perfect as He is the All-knowing. The same cannot be said about the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings upon him. This phrase was said by some Sahabah, such as Umar r.a. in the Hadith of Gibril, however that was possible then by virtue of the Prophet, peace and blessings, having revelation. Having said this, it is still permitted to say the phrase by way of narrating a hadith that has this phrase.

The answer given above is the opinion of the scholar who has answered the question and does not reflect the opinion of other scholars, volunteers or employees of As-Suffa Institute and As-Suffa Institute as an organisation.

Copyright As-Suffa Institute - Registered Charity: 1106270